Top 10 Mystery Series You Need to Watch in 2025
Mystery series have long captivated audiences with their intricate plots, suspenseful storytelling, and mind-bending twists. Whether it’s a classic detective story, a psychological thriller, or a crime-solving saga, these shows keep viewers on the edge of their seats. With 2025 fast approaching, the world of mystery television is set to deliver even more gripping and unpredictable narratives. From psychological mysteries to crime procedurals, there’s no shortage of thrilling content. Here are the top 10 mystery series you need to watch in 2025.
1. “The Night Agent” (Season 2)
Genre: Political Thriller, Mystery, Crime
Where to Watch: Netflix
A breakout hit in recent years, The Night Agent mixes political intrigue with a deep mystery at its core. The series follows Peter Sutherland, an FBI agent, who becomes embroiled in a conspiracy involving the highest levels of government. After the explosive events of Season 1, Season 2 promises more twists, betrayals, and high-stakes action. If you love a gripping combination of espionage, mystery, and personal stakes, this is a must-watch in 2025.
Why Watch:
- High-stakes political thriller
- Complex characters and intense plotting
- Intricate conspiracy that keeps you guessing
2. “The Woman in the House Across the Street from the Girl in the Window” (Season 2)
Genre: Psychological Thriller, Mystery, Dark Comedy
Where to Watch: Netflix
The first season of this unique mystery series was a wild ride, mixing dark humor with intense psychological suspense. In The Woman in the House Across the Street from the Girl in the Window, the protagonist, Anna, is trying to uncover the truth behind the suspicious death of her neighbor. With the success of its first season, fans are eagerly awaiting Season 2, which promises more twists, mind games, and shocking reveals.
Why Watch:
- A hilarious yet chilling mix of dark comedy and psychological thriller
- Great character development and unexpected twists
- Unpredictable plot with numerous red herrings
3. “The Pale Blue Eye”
Genre: Historical Mystery, Crime, Thriller
Where to Watch: Netflix (2025 Release)
Based on the novel by Louis Bayard, The Pale Blue Eye is set in 1830s West Point and follows the investigation into a gruesome murder at the prestigious military academy. The twist? The investigation involves a young Edgar Allan Poe, who was a cadet at the time. The eerie setting, historical backdrop, and literary twist are all set to make this one of the most intriguing mystery series of 2025.
Why Watch:
- A fresh take on Edgar Allan Poe’s early life
- Gritty, atmospheric mystery set in a historical context
- Perfect blend of real events and fictional drama
4. “The Outsider” (Season 2)
Genre: Supernatural Mystery, Thriller, Crime
Where to Watch: HBO Max
Based on Stephen King’s novel, The Outsider Season 1 was a haunting and intense crime thriller involving the investigation of a brutal murder, which appears to have supernatural elements. With Season 2 on the horizon, expect more eerie investigations, chilling mysteries, and a deeper dive into the supernatural forces at play. The combination of crime-solving with supernatural elements makes it an unmissable show for fans of both genres.
Why Watch:
- Gripping, supernatural crime mystery
- Based on Stephen King’s best-selling novel
- A unique blend of police procedural and horror
5. “Lockwood & Co.”
Genre: Supernatural Mystery, Thriller, Fantasy
Where to Watch: Netflix
Set in a world where ghosts and supernatural entities roam freely, Lockwood & Co. follows a young team of ghost hunters as they solve mysteries involving paranormal activity. This series is based on Jonathan Stroud’s popular books, and it combines the intrigue of mystery-solving with the thrill of ghost-hunting. With a youthful and dynamic cast, this show promises to be a fun yet suspenseful watch in 2025.
Why Watch:
- Supernatural mystery with a thrilling edge
- Strong, likable cast with plenty of chemistry
- Combines mystery and fantasy in a fresh way
6. “The Secret Agent’s Shadow”
Genre: Spy Mystery, Thriller
Where to Watch: Hulu
This new espionage series delves into the world of covert operations, surveillance, and hidden agendas. The show follows a former secret agent who becomes entangled in a global conspiracy after uncovering a dangerous secret. As he works to expose a shadowy organization, the lines between friend and foe blur. The Secret Agent’s Shadow promises to be a gripping blend of spy thriller and complex mystery.
Why Watch:
- Thrilling spy drama with intricate plot twists
- Strong central character struggling with his own past
- Suspenseful pacing with plenty of edge-of-your-seat moments
7. “The Big Chill”
Genre: Mystery, Psychological Drama, Thriller
Where to Watch: Amazon Prime Video
A group of old college friends reunites for a weekend getaway, only to be plunged into a series of mysterious and deadly events. The Big Chill examines the hidden secrets of the group as they try to uncover the truth behind a series of strange incidents that seem to be connected to their past. With plenty of twists and turns, this psychological mystery is bound to keep viewers hooked.
Why Watch:
- Mystery with deep character-driven drama
- A perfect blend of suspense and psychological elements
- Strong ensemble cast and intense emotional stakes
8. “The Evidence Room”
Genre: Crime Mystery, Thriller
Where to Watch: HBO Max
The Evidence Room takes a unique approach to the classic crime procedural by focusing on the cold case department of a large metropolitan police force. The team revisits old, unsolved cases, using new technology and insights to uncover the truth. Each episode unpacks a different cold case while gradually revealing a larger, interconnected mystery involving the department itself.
Why Watch:
- Unique spin on the crime procedural genre
- Slow-burn storytelling with deep investigations
- Complex, multi-layered mystery with a compelling ensemble cast
9. “The Vanishing Point”
Genre: Psychological Mystery, Thriller
Where to Watch: Apple TV+
In this psychological thriller, a detective investigates a series of disappearances that seem to occur without a trace. As the investigation unfolds, it becomes clear that the missing persons may not just be victims of crime—they may be linked to a far more disturbing mystery. With its eerie atmosphere and complex narrative, The Vanishing Point promises to be one of the most suspenseful mystery shows of 2025.
Why Watch:
- Dark, atmospheric storytelling
- Psychological twists that keep you guessing
- Deep exploration of character motivations and secrets
10. “Murder by the Book”
Genre: Literary Mystery, Thriller
Where to Watch: BBC One (International Release Pending)
This unique mystery series combines crime-solving with the world of literature. The show follows a retired detective turned private investigator who is hired to solve a high-profile murder involving a famous author. As the investigation unfolds, it becomes clear that the murder is linked to the author’s latest book—and the dark secrets contained within it. If you’re a fan of books within books, this is the series for you.
Why Watch:
- A literary twist on the classic murder mystery
- Intricate plot with well-developed characters
- Engaging mix of crime-solving and literary references
Final Thoughts
With 2025 right around the corner, the world of mystery television is set to deliver an incredible lineup of shows that will leave you on the edge of your seat. From supernatural thrillers to psychological dramas, there’s something for every type of mystery lover. So, grab your popcorn, settle in, and prepare for a year filled with suspense, twists, and unforgettable moments. These top 10 mystery series are guaranteed to keep you guessing until the very end.
